Photo: AshBoar, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0Cheapest car insurance in South Africa (2026)
What sets the price and how to pay less
Free, no obligation. Only insurers and brokers licensed by the Prudential Authority (insurers) or the FSCA (brokers) receive your request.
Get free quotesOn this page · 7 sections
Why no honest "top 10 cheapest" list exists
Car insurers in South Africa do not sell from a price list. They quote each driver on a risk profile, so the insurer that is cheapest for one person can be the dearest for the next. Two insurers say it in their own words:
- MiWay: "The cost of your car insurance depends on a bunch of 'risk' factors, like your age, your driving experience, your car's make and model, and its location in the day and at night" (MiWay FAQs, seen November 2026).
- OUTsurance: the premium is calculated from the car's make, model, year and value (including whether it is financed), the cover option, private or business use, and also your location, your driving and claims history, the excess you select, security features such as tracking and any add-ons (OUTsurance car insurance, seen November 2026).
A ranking of "cheapest insurers" would therefore describe one invented driver, not you. Tulinde does not rank insurers or publish premiums it cannot verify.
What sets your car insurance premium
The factors OUTsurance and MiWay publish, grouped by who controls them:
| Factor | Can you change it? | Named by |
|---|---|---|
| Age and driving experience | No | MiWay |
| Driving and claims history | Over time, by not claiming | OUTsurance |
| Make, model, year and value of the car | Only when you choose the car | OUTsurance, MiWay |
| Where the car is kept, day and night | Rarely | MiWay, OUTsurance (location) |
| Private or business use | Declare it as it is | OUTsurance |
| Cover type (for example third party or comprehensive) | Yes | OUTsurance |
| Excess level | Yes | OUTsurance, MiWay |
| Security features such as tracking | Yes | OUTsurance |
| Add-ons and benefits | Yes | OUTsurance |
Sources: OUTsurance and MiWay, the insurers' own pages, seen November 2026. Each insurer weighs these factors its own way, which is why the same driver gets very different quotes.
Four legal ways to lower your premium
- Choose the cover type the car needs. OUTsurance lists third party, comprehensive and its Essential option, and advises choosing "the level of cover that matches your needs ... instead of paying for features you don't need"; MiWay sells Comprehensive, Lite and Total Loss. Third party only pays for damage you cause to others, not your own car: see third party vs comprehensive.
- Raise the excess only to what you can pay. MiWay sets a standard excess of R5 000 and lets you "dial your excess up or down": "the lower your excess, the higher your monthly premium payment, and vice versa." In MiWay's own example, on an approved claim of R50 000 with that excess you pay the first R5 000 and it pays R45 000.
- Insure the right value, not the lowest. MiWay offers retail value (what a dealer would charge, the highest), market value (the average selling price, the middle) and trade value (what a dealer would give you, the lowest). Underinsuring to save is a false saving: the National Financial Ombud warns that an insurer may then apply "average", which "may result in a significantly reduced pay-out" (NFO tips).
- Remove the extras you would not use, and question bonuses. Under rule 10.14 of the short-term Policyholder Protection Rules, an advert for a no-claim bonus must not suggest it is free and must say whether it is optional and what it costs, unless that cost is under 10% of the premium. OUTsurance's own OUTbonus pays back 10% of paid car premiums after three consecutive claim-free years.
Sources: OUTsurance, MiWay, seen November 2026.
Where a cheap quote turns expensive
The ombud's figures show where savings go wrong. In the 2023 financial year, the NFO's non-life division reported that around 40% of all its complaints came from motor insurance, mostly accident claims declined on the basis of an exclusion; among the predominant reasons was "misrepresentation or non-disclosure at the time of taking out the policy" (NFO).
- Wrong answers to get a lower price. Naming a lower-risk regular driver, another overnight address or private use for a car used for work can lower the quote and then sink the claim.
- The first premium. The NFO notes that if you do not pay the first premium, cover does not begin, because the 15-day grace period does not apply to it (NFO tips).
- Stopping the debit order to switch. The NFO advises "not to simply put a stop payment order on your premium payments because this will result in your policy being cancelled": cancel the old policy in writing once the new one is in force.
- Security conditions. A quote that assumes a tracker is only valid if the tracker is fitted and working; the NFO adds that some policies require two tracking devices on frequently targeted makes (NFO tips).
How to compare quotes like for like, and keep the price in check
The short-term Policyholder Protection Rules give you the tools to compare and to watch the price after you sign:
| When | What the insurer must do | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Before you sign | Give details of any premium increases, including their frequency and basis | 11.4.2(e)(iii) |
| After you sign | Let you cancel within 14 days of receiving the policy, on a policy longer than 31 days with no claim | 4.2 |
| Before renewal | At least 31 days before, tell you in writing the renewal premium next to the premium last paid | 11.6.5 |
- Ask each insurer to quote the same car, cover type, excess and insured value, with the same drivers and overnight address.
- Write down the monthly premium, every excess and any extra or bonus included in the price.
- Ask how and when the premium may increase, and whether it is guaranteed.
- At each renewal, compare the new premium with the one you paid and get fresh quotes if it rose.
To receive several quotes from licensed insurers for the same car and cover, ask for free quotes.
Already insured?
Next step
Frequently asked questions
Which is the cheapest car insurance in South Africa?
None is cheapest for everyone. Insurers such as MiWay and OUTsurance price each driver on age, driving experience, the car, where it is kept, claims history, cover type and excess, so only quotes for the same car and cover show which is cheapest for you.
What is the cheapest type of car insurance?
Third party only covers the least: damage you cause to other people's vehicles and property, nothing for your own car. Third party, fire and theft adds theft and fire; comprehensive adds accident damage to your car. Compare the premium for each type on the same car before you choose.
Does a higher excess make car insurance cheaper?
Yes: OUTsurance says a higher excess can often lower the premium, and MiWay that the lower your excess, the higher your premium. Choose only an excess you could pay on a claim tomorrow.
How much of my car premium is Sasria?
For a private car, R26.23 a year or R2.62 a month under Sasria's rates schedule effective 1 October 2025. Your insurer collects it with your premium.
Can my insurer raise my car premium at renewal?
It can, but under rule 11.6.5 of the Policyholder Protection Rules it must tell you in writing at least 31 days before renewal the new premium and the premium last paid, so you can compare and shop around.
Sources
- Sasria SOC Ltd — Updated Rates Schedule, effective 1 October 2025 (v4, published July 2026): Motor, cars (private use), rate code M1
- Policyholder Protection Rules (Short-term Insurance), 2017 — GN 1433, Government Gazette 41329, 15 December 2017 (gov.za): rules 4.2, 10.14, 11.4.2 and 11.6.5
- National Financial Ombud — Always read policy fine print to avoid headaches when making a claim (motor complaints in the 2023 financial year)
- National Financial Ombud — Non-life insurance tips: premiums paid in advance, first premium, debit orders, underinsurance
- OUTsurance — Car insurance: how the premium is calculated, excess, cover options, OUTbonus (insurer's own page, seen 21 November 2026)
- MiWay — FAQs: risk factors, cover options, standard R5 000 excess, retail, trade and market value (insurer's own page, seen 21 November 2026)